On Thursday 16 February, Prof David Collins, Head of the Suffolk Business School, presented some research on Make America Great…Again: The Excellence Project in Retrospect. A version of this paper, translated into Spanish, will appear in the journal ‘Debats’ in late 2017. In the meantime, a downloadable version is available here:
In my previous blog I suggested that my knowledge of the world and my educational aspirations had been boosted by watching television throughout my childhood. In addition I acknowledged that – thanks in part to my viewing habits – I have throughout my adult life pursued a research interest in managerial storytelling. Since at least one of these sentences is potentially controversial it is, I think, worth taking a few moments to offer some clarification.
When I suggest that watching television during the 1970s altered my educational aspiration and in so doing shaped my adult life I do not mean to imply that television programming during the 1970s was in any sense good. Much of it in fact was awful. Indeed a significant proportion was it was racist and sexist. But some of it was brilliant.
I used to think that it was a couple of documentaries prepared by BBC Scotland on the decline of shipbuilding and the restructuring of coal-mining which had sparked my interest in social organization and in management more generally. Until I saw these programmes I had been planning to become a metallurgist like my big brother before me. I now realise, however, that it was a combination of my school’s organic chemistry curriculum combined with a rather special television series which had convinced me that I might like to research the organizational world.
The remarkable series of programmes which I now realise shaped my understanding of the world and my future plans – even before I was fully aware of its impact upon me is: The World at War.
What was it about this series that influenced me so deeply? Well I suppose it’s a combination of things. Partly it’s the archive film footage. Partly it’s the quality of the interviewees. Partly I suppose it’s because the ordinary men and women who were interviewed, often sitting together in pubs, looked just like my parents and had shared their experiences.
But a big part of the credit must go to the writer of the scripts, Mark Arnold-Foster, and to the narrator, Sir Laurence Olivier who, together managed to weave archive footage and contemporary interviews in a fashion that, to this day, captures the horror and the nobility; the terror and the humour of this conflict.
One episode in particular struck me as being especially powerful (I shy away from using the word ‘good’ for reasons that will soon become clear). This episode is entitled ‘Remember’ and has many striking scenes. In one particularly significant passage Olivier talks over film footage of Russian villagers being herded away by German soldiers. He is doing this to remind just how horribly Russians suffered during the war. After a few moments he falls quiet so that we may take in the film footage.
As their village burns behind them the women in the film are separated from the men. Soon the men will be killed in cold blood. As the soldiers began to enforce the separation and intervene roughly to push the women away from their men, Olivier begins to speak again. But he is no longer talking over the scene, he has become part of it even has he remains off camera. My blood runs cold as he says in a quiet yet urbane tone, ‘Hurry things along corporal’.
Are you still wondering why I find storytelling to be such a powerful medium for managerial research?
Some further reading:
Collins, D (2011) ‘Women roar: ‘The women’s thing’ in the storywork of Tom Peters’ Organization 19(4) pp 405-424
Collins, D (2012) ‘In search of popular management: Sensemaking, sensegiving and
storytelling in the excellence project’ Culture and Organization pp 1-20
Collins, D & K Rainwater (2005) ‘Managing change at Sears: a sideways look at a tale of corporate transformation’ Journal of Organizational Change Management 18(1) pp 16 – 30
To discuss these works, or managerial storytelling, please email email@example.com
In my previous blog I made no fewer than three reading recommendations and yet confessed that I did not actually take up reading seriously until I was around 16. I should probably take a moment to expand upon this revelation…
It’s true I did not actually take up reading seriously until I was around sixteen. How had I spent my time prior to that? Well I had been playing soldiers (my father and all my uncles had seen action in World War II), playing football (poorly), playing basketball (with a little more flair, but if you ever meet me, you will see that this was not going to go anywhere). I had also been watching television.
All this ceased abruptly when I was sixteen. My family moved from Kilmarnock to a very small town called Newmilns and my father returned our old rented television (yes people rented televisions in those days!) and simply refused to buy a replacement. So I guess you are now thinking that this is the part of the story where I say… ‘And at this point, having been denied easy access to the mind-numbing so-called entertainment that is television I turned to reading, quickly devoured all the classics, and in so doing took the first steps on a path that would lead me to an academic career.’
Well I’m sorry to disappoint you, but this is not how the story goes. Truthfully I was miserable. My friends now lived miles away and the things that I would normally do to keep me occupied on a winter’s evening (watching television and road-running) were now no longer options (the roads in our little town were not lit). And in any case, the narrative of my transformation from viewer to reader fails because I had decided that I would like to become an academic two years previously!
So how did a boy from a working-class community, with no previous exposure to University study let alone academic careers, come to this decision aged fourteen? Well, the example set by some good teachers plainly helped. But the truth, as far as I am concerned, is that watching television improved my education. Watching really good television programmes had fuelled my curiosity, and it had begun to teach me that you could educate and entertain. Indeed television had taught me that education was pretty much impossible in the absence of an engaging narrative. It’s probably not surprising therefore that much of my research on the practices and processes of managing has focused upon storytelling.
So what’s my point? I guess what I’m trying to say is that if you feel that your background and biography somehow disqualify you from higher education, think again. I transitioned fairly quickly from not reading books to writing my own and there’s no reason why you can’t so the same.
The University of Suffolk is committed to supporting students from all backgrounds succeed in their chosen careers. Explore our range of degrees here. Professor David Collins is the Head of the Suffolk Business School, which offers undergraduate degrees in:
- BA (Hons) Accounting and Financial Management
- BA (Hons) Business Management
- BA (Hons) Event Management
- BA (Hons) Event Management and Tourism Management
- BA (Hons) Tourism Management
We also offer postgraduate qualifications in:
- Master of Business Administration (MBA)
- MSc Business and Management
- PgD Human Resource Management
- MSc Human Resource Management